Short-Term Disability Claims and Appeals

The Short-Term Disability Claims Process

Step 1: Determine Your Eligibility

Before initiating your claim, understanding your policy’s specific requirements is critical. Most short-term disability policies require:

• A qualifying medical condition preventing work performance
• Active employment when your disability begins
• Completion of any elimination period (typically 0-14 days)
• Medical documentation substantiating your condition and work limitations

Our short-term disability lawyers in Toronto can review your policy details to verify eligibility and identify potential complications before submitting your claim.

Step 2: Gather Complete Medical Documentation

Insurance companies won’t simply take your word that you’re unable to work—they need verification from healthcare professionals. Your file should include recent clinical records that clearly outline your diagnosis, its severity, and any resulting functional limitations. Your treatment plan must demonstrate you’re actively working toward recovery, as insurers may question claims where patients aren’t following medical advice. A short-term disability benefits lawyer can help coordinate with your healthcare providers to ensure they understand what documentation is most helpful for your claim, often obtaining specialized reports that directly address how your condition affects your ability to perform specific job functions.

Step 3: Complete Application Forms

The application for short-term disability contains several interconnected documents that must tell a consistent story about your condition. Your personal statement should clearly describe how your symptoms prevent you from performing essential job tasks, while avoiding contradictions with other documentation. Your employer’s portion verifies employment details but also outlines job requirements, which the insurer will compare against your claimed limitations. Your doctor’s statement must specifically connect your medical condition to your work restrictions. Our short-term disability lawyer in Ontario helps align these statements to prevent the inconsistencies that frequently trigger denials.

Step 4: Submit Your Claim and Monitor Progress

Once submitted, your claim enters an evaluation phase during which the insurance company might employ various tactics to test its validity. They may contact your medical providers directly seeking clarification, request you attend appointments with their physicians, or even monitor your social media for contradictory evidence. Our short-term disability benefits lawyer serves as an intermediary, fielding questions from the insurer, preparing you for any evaluations, and ensuring all follow-up documentation reaches the correct departments on time.

Step 5: Respond to the Insurer’s Decision

If your claim is approved, we’ll explain your rights and obligations while receiving benefits. If denied, we immediately begin developing your appeal strategy.

Denied STD Claims and the Appeals Process

Receiving a denial letter when you genuinely cannot work can be both frustrating and frightening. However, a denial doesn’t mark the end of your claim. Our short-term disability lawyer in Toronto can help you understand the reasons for rejection and create an effective strategy to challenge the decision.

Common Reasons for Denial

Insurance companies deny short-term disability claims for various reasons, including:

• Insufficient medical evidence supporting your inability to work
• Failure to meet filing deadlines or incomplete documentation
• Surveillance evidence supposedly contradicting your reported limitations
• Policy exclusions for certain conditions
• Administrative errors in processing your claim
• Disagreement about your recovery timeline

Understanding precisely why your claim was denied is essential for building a successful appeal. Our short-term disability lawyer in Ontario thoroughly reviews denial letters and your file to identify the specific issues requiring attention.

The Internal Appeal Process

When insurers deny your short-term disability claim, the first avenue for challenge is typically through their internal review system. This administrative procedure requires careful preparation within strict timeframes—often just 30 to 60 days from receiving your denial notice. During this time, you must directly counter each reason cited in the denial letter with fresh supporting evidence. Our short-term disability lawyers understand what evidence resonates with specific insurance companies and how to frame your appeal to address their concerns.

External Appeals and Litigation

When internal appeals fail to reverse a denial, taking legal action becomes your primary recourse. This shift from administrative to legal proceedings shifts the dynamics in your favour, as courts are less inclined to automatically side with insurance company interpretations. The litigation process typically follows these steps:

1. Your short-term disability lawyer in Toronto drafts and files a Statement of Claim that details how the insurer breached its contractual obligations to provide benefits despite your qualifying condition.
2. The insurance company responds with a Statement of Defence, arguing that their decision was reasonable based on available evidence.
3. Both parties engage in document exchange, where all relevant claim materials, internal notes, and assessment reports must be shared.
4. We may attend mediation to negotiate a settlement. If unsuccessful, your case proceeds to trial, though most cases settle before reaching this stage.

Throughout these proceedings, our short-term disability lawyer in Ontario builds your case while shielding you from the direct stress of legal confrontations, allowing you to focus on your health concerns rather than legal complexities.

Contact Us

Are you struggling with a short-term disability claim while also trying to manage your health condition? Contact us for a no-obligation consultation with a short-term disability lawyer in Toronto who can assess your case, explain your options, and develop a practical strategy for your claim.

BOOK YOUR FREE CONSULTATION

FAQs About Short-Term Disability Claims and Appeals

Do I Need a Lawyer for Short-Term Disability?

While not always necessary for initial applications, consulting a lawyer for a short-term disability claim can be extremely beneficial, especially in certain situations:

• When your claim has been denied
• If you have a complex medical condition that’s difficult to document
• When your insurer is requesting surveillance or independent medical examinations
• If you’re experiencing unreasonable delays in processing
• When your employer disputes your claim
• If your benefits are terminated prematurely before you can return to work

Our short-term disability lawyers in Toronto provide an initial free consultation to assess your situation and advise whether legal representation would benefit your case. Insurance companies have extensive legal resources protecting their interests – having your own legal advocate levels the playing field and ensures your rights are equally protected.

How Much Does It Cost to Hire a Lawyer for Short-Term Disability Claims?

At Matthews Abogado, we understand that individuals facing disability-related financial pressures cannot typically afford substantial upfront legal fees. We operate on a contingency fee basis for short-term disability claims, meaning you pay no legal fees unless we successfully recover benefits or a settlement on your behalf.

The contingency arrangement aligns our interests with yours – we only get paid when you receive your benefits. This approach removes financial barriers to quality legal representation, enabling you to focus on your health and recovery while we handle the legal aspects of securing your disability benefits.

What’s the Difference Between Short-Term and Long-Term Disability Claims?

These are the primary differences between short-term and long-term disability claims:

• Short-term disability typically provides benefits for 3-6 months, while long-term disability can continue for years or even until retirement age.
• Short-term disability usually requires you to be unable to perform your own occupation. Long-term disability often begins with this definition, but may transition to an “any occupation” standard after a certain period.
• Short-term disability benefits typically begin after a brief waiting period (0-14 days), while long-term disability usually has a longer elimination period (often 3-6 months).
• Short-term disability typically replaces 55% of your income, while long-term disability benefits might be slightly higher (60-70%).
• While both require medical evidence, long-term disability claims often face more rigorous scrutiny and require more extensive documentation of ongoing impairment.

Our short-term disability lawyers in Ontario can help determine which benefits you qualify for and guide you through transitioning from short-term to long-term benefits if your condition persists beyond the short-term benefit period.